The Western States Trail Foundation must acknowledge the unfortunate loss of two horses during the 2024 Tevis Cup ride.
Max Merlich lost his horse Laylas Knightly Getaway (“Layla”) in the Swinging Bridge Canyon near Devil’s Thumb, more than 50 miles into the ride.
Caroline DeBourbon lost her mount (owned by Melissa Montgomery) MV Im Hot N
Bothered (“Phoenix”) on the California Loop close to the Cal 2 water stop, more than 75 miles from the start. Both horses tragically fell off the trail in precipitous locations after reacting violently to issues on the ground and with tack.
Specially trained large animal rescue teams on call for the event were dispatched to both locations as rapidly as possible. The teams were accompanied by emergency veterinarians. Neither horse was recoverable and both were euthanized in place in accordance with their owner’s wishes.
Riders and owners of the horses have expressed their gratitude for the quick response and help they received from the Tevis emergency teams and the WSTF Board of Governors strongly echoes that sentiment.
While no responsibility for the incidents has been placed on the event or the trail itself by those involved, WSTF will absolutely conduct a full review to determine if any action can be taken to help mitigate tragic outcomes. However, it must be acknowledged the historic Western States Trail includes very precipitous sections which cannot be fully mitigated and – combined with unfortunate equine reactions – have the potential to result in tragedy.
WSTF will share findings and any recommendations with the public in the next few weeks. Specific suggestions for improvements or items for consideration can be sent to WSTF at WSTF@TevisCup.org.
In the meantime, the Endurance family needs to come together. Placing blame publicly is detrimental to both the sport and this event. Please join us extending our deepest condolences to everyone whose lives have been touched by these two beautiful animals.
They will be missed.